A Protocol to Assess Time-of-Day-Dependent Learning and Memory in Mice Using the Novel Object Recognition Test
Changes in learning and memory are important behavioral readouts of brain function across multiple species. In mice, a multitude of behavioral tasks exist to study learning and memory, including those influenced by extrinsic and intrinsic forces such as stress (e.g., escape from danger, hunger, or thirst) or natural curiosity and exploratory drive. The novel object recognition (NOR) test is a widely used behavioral paradigm to study memory and learning under various conditions, including age, sex, motivational state, and neural circuit dynamics. Although mice are nocturnal, many behavioral tests are performed during their inactive period (light phase, subjective night) for the convenience of the diurnal experimenters. However, learning and memory are strongly associated with the animal’s sleep-wake and circadian cycles, stressing the need to test these behaviors during the animals’ active period (dark phase, subjective day). Here, we develop a protocol to perform the NOR task during both light (subjective night) and dark (subjective day) phases in adult mice (4 months old) and provide a flexible framework to test the learning and memory components of this task at distinct times of day and associated activity periods. We also highlight methodological details critical for obtaining the expected behavioral responses.
Constructing and Implementing a Low-Cost On-Demand Morris Water Maze Platform
The Morris water maze (MWM) is one of the most widely used procedures to assess hippocampus-dependent spatial learning and memory in rodents. By varying test protocols, researchers can test several different domains of learning and memory. Over multiple testing days, animals learn to swim to a platform hidden just under the water surface by using the spatial relationship between distal cues and the platform. Probe trials, where the platform is rendered unavailable, measure rodents’ spatial bias for the area where the platform was previously located. The ability of researchers to control the availability of the platform “on-demand” offers both practical and methodological advantages. Despite MWM’s prominence in the field of behavioral neuroscience, the high cost of purchasing a commercial MWM package is often prohibitively expensive for many research labs, especially on-demand platforms. Here, we describe a low-cost strategy for a build-your-own MWM that includes a remote-controlled on-demand platform (~530 USD) and tank (~550 USD). It is our hope that disseminating low-cost strategies aimed at expanding access to high-quality research tools at underfunded research institutions will accelerate biomedical discovery and foster further innovation.
Semi-Automated Assessment of Long-Term Olfactory Habituation in Drosophila melanogaster Using the Olfactory Arena
Long-lasting memories are a core aspect of an animal’s life. Such memories are characterized by unique molecular mechanisms and often unique circuitry, neither of which are completely understood in vivo. The deep knowledge of the identity and connectivity of neurons of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, as well as the sophisticated genetic tools that allow in vivo perturbations and physiology monitoring, make it a remarkably useful organism in which to investigate the molecular mechanisms of long-term memories. In this protocol, we focus on habituation, a non-associative form of learning, and describe a reliable, semi-automated technique to induce and assess long-term olfactory habituation (LTH) in Drosophila using the olfactory arena, thus providing a method aligned with recent technological progress in behavioral measurement. Prior work has shown that LTH is induced by a 4-day exposure to an odorant and is characterized by a long-lasting (> 24 h) reduction in behavioral response to the exposed odorant, measured using a manual and skill-intensive Y-maze assay. Here, we present a semi-automated protocol for obtaining quantifiable measures of LTH, at the level of detail required for other investigators in the field. Unlike previously described methods, the protocol presented here provides quantitative and detailed behavioral measurements obtained by video recording that can be shared with the scientific community and allows sophisticated forms of offline analysis. We suggest that this procedure has the potential to advance our understanding of molecular and circuit mechanisms of olfactory habituation, its control via neuromodulation, and its interactions with other forms of memory.
Habituation of Sugar-Induced Proboscis Extension Reflex and Yeast-Induced Habituation Override in Drosophila melanogaster
Habituation, the process by which animals learn to ignore insignificant stimuli, facilitates engagement with salient features of the environment. However, neural mechanisms underlying habituation also allow responses to familiar stimuli to be reinstated when such stimuli become potentially significant. Thus, the habituated state must allow a mechanism for habituation override. The remarkably precise knowledge of cell identity, connectivity, and information coding in Drosophila sensory circuits, as well as the availability of tools to genetically target these cells, makes Drosophila a valuable and important organism for analysis of habituation and habituation-override mechanisms. Studies of olfactory and gustatory habituation in Drosophila suggest that potentiation of GABAergic neurons underlies certain timescales of habituation and have specified some elements of a gustatory habituation-override pathway. More detailed understanding of gustatory habituation and habituation-override mechanisms will benefit from access to robust behavioral assays for (a) the proboscis extension reflex (PER) elicited by a sweet stimulus, (b) exposure paradigms that result in PER habituation, and, most critically, (c) manipulations that result in PER-habituation override. Here, we describe simple protocols for persistent sucrose exposure of tarsal hairs that lead to habituation of proboscis extension and for presentation of a novel appetitive stimuli that reinstate robust PER to habituated flies. This detailed protocol of gustatory habituation provides (a) a simple method to induce habituation by continuous exposure of the flies to sucrose for 10 min without leading to ingestion and (b) a novel method to override habituation by presenting yeast to the proboscis.
Key features
• A protocol for stimulation of Drosophila’s taste (sugar) sensory neurons that induces gustatory habituation without satiation due to ingestion.
• A chemical (yeast) stimulation protocol that rapidly induces habituation override/dishabituation in sugar-habituated Drosophila.
Caste Transition and Reversion in Harpegnathos saltator Ant Colonies
Living organisms possess the ability to respond to environmental cues and adapt their behaviors and physiologies for survival. Eusocial insects, such as ants, bees, wasps, and termites, have evolved advanced sociality: living together in colonies where individuals innately develop into reproductive and non-reproductive castes. These castes exhibit remarkably distinct behaviors and physiologies that support their specialized roles in the colony. Among ant species, Harpegnathos saltator females stand out with their highly plastic caste phenotypes that can be easily manipulated in a laboratory environment. In this protocol, we provide detailed instructions on how to generate H. saltator ant colonies, define castes based on behavioral and physiological phenotypes, and experimentally induce caste switches, including the transition from a non-reproductive worker to a reproductive gamergate and vice versa (known as reversion). The unusual features of H. saltator make it a valuable tool to investigate cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying phenotypic plasticity in eusocial organisms.
Key features
• H. saltator is one of few ant species showing remarkable caste plasticity with striking phenotypic changes, being a useful subject for studying behavioral plasticity.
• Caste switches in H. saltator can be easily manipulated in a controlled laboratory environment by controlling the presence of reproductive females in a colony.
• The relatively large size of H. saltator females allows researchers to dissect various tissues of interest and conduct detailed phenotypic analyses.
A Method for Studying Social Signal Learning of the Waggle Dance in Honey Bees
Honey bees use a complex form of spatial referential communication. Their waggle dance communicates to nestmates the direction, distance, and quality of a resource by encoding celestial cues, retinal optic flow, and relative food value into motion and sound within the nest. This protocol was developed to investigate the potential for social learning of this waggle dance. Using this protocol, we showed that correct waggle dancing requires social learning. Bees (Apis mellifera) that did not follow any dances before they first danced produced significantly more disordered dances, with larger waggle angle divergence errors, and encoded distance incorrectly. The former deficits improved with experience, but distance encoding was set for life. The first dances of bees that could follow other dancers had none of these impairments. Social learning, therefore, shapes honey bee signaling, as it does communication in human infants, birds, and multiple other vertebrate species. However, much remains to be learned about insects’ social learning, and this protocol will help to address knowledge gaps in the understanding of sophisticated social signal learning, particularly in understanding the molecular bases for such learning.
Key features
• It was unclear if honey bees (Apis mellifera) could improve their waggle dance by following experienced dancers before they first waggle dance.
• Honey bees perform their first waggle dances with more errors if they cannot follow experienced waggle dancers first.
• Directional and disorder errors improved over time, but distance error was maintained. Bees in experimental colonies continued to communicate longer distances than control bees.
• Dancing correctly, with less directional error and disorder, requires social learning.
• Distance encoding in the honey bee dance is largely genetic but may also include a component of cultural transmission.
Conditioned Lick Suppression: Assessing Contextual, Cued, and Context-cue Compound Fear Responses Independently of Locomotor Activity in Mice
Pavlovian fear conditioning is a widely used procedure to assess learning and memory processes that has also been extensively used as a model of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Freezing, the absence of movement except for respiratory-related movements, is commonly used as a measure of fear response in non-human animals. However, this measure of fear responses can be affected by a different baseline of locomotor activity between groups and/or conditions. Moreover, fear conditioning procedures are usually restricted to a single conditioned stimulus (e.g., a tone cue, the context, etc.) and thus do not depict the complexity of real-life situations where traumatic memories are composed of a complex set of stimuli associated with the same aversive event. To overcome this issue, we use a conditioned lick suppression paradigm where water-deprived mice are presented with a single conditioned stimulus (CS, a tone cue or the context) previously paired with an unconditioned stimulus (US, a foot shock) while consuming water. We use the ratio of number of licks before and during the CS presentation as a fear measure, thereby neutralizing the potential effect of locomotor activity in fear responses. We further implemented the conditioned lick suppression ratio to assess the effect of cue competition using a compound of contextual and tone cue conditioned stimuli that were extinguished separately. This paradigm should prove useful in assessing potential therapeutics and/or behavioral therapies in PTSD, while neutralizing potential confounding effects between locomotor activity and fear responses on one side, and by considering potential cue-competition effects on the other side.
Graphical abstract
Schematic representation of the compound context-cue condition lick suppression procedure. Illustration reproduced from Bouchekioua et al. (2022).
Protocol to Study Spatial Subgoal Learning Using Escape Behavior in Mice
Rodent spatial navigation is a key model system for studying mammalian cognition and its neural mechanisms. Of particular interest is how animals memorize the structure of their environments and compute multi-step routes to a goal. Previous work on multi-step spatial reasoning has generally involved placing rodents at the start of a maze until they learn to navigate to a reward without making wrong turns. It thus remains poorly understood how animals rapidly learn about the structure of naturalistic open environments with goals and obstacles. Here we present an assay in which mice spontaneously memorize two-step routes in an environment with a shelter and an obstacle. We allow the mice to explore this environment for 20 min, and then we remove the obstacle. We then present auditory threat stimuli, causing the mouse to escape to the shelter. Finally, we record each escape route and measure whether it targets the shelter directly (a ‘homing-vector’ escape) or instead targets the location where the obstacle edge was formerly located (an ‘edge-vector’ escape). Since the obstacle is no longer there, these obstacle-edge-directed escape routes provide evidence that the mouse has memorized a subgoal location,i.e., a waypoint targeted in order to efficiently get to the shelter in the presence of an obstacle. By taking advantage of instinctive escape responses, this assay probes a multi-step spatial memory that is learned in a single session without pretraining. The subgoal learning phenomenon it generates can be useful not only for researchers working on navigation and instinctive behavior, but also for neuroscientists studying the neural basis of multi-step spatial reasoning.
A Simple Spatial-independent Associative and Reversal Learning Task in Mice
The ability to adapt one's behavior in response to changing circumstances, or cognitive flexibility, is often altered in neuropsychiatric and neurodevelopmental conditions. In rodents, cognitive flexibility is frequently assessed using associative learning paradigms with a reversal component. The majority of existing protocols rely on unrestrictive exploration with no discouragement of wrong responses and are often influenced by spatial cues, at least during the test's learning phase. Here, we present a rewarded contingency discrimination learning test that minimizes the task's spatial component and contains an element that actively discourages pure exploratory responses. The method described herein is a manual version that can be performed using home-made equipment, but the test setup is amenable to automatization and can be adapted to address more complex cognitive demands, including conditional associative learning, attentional set formation, and attention shifting.
An Alternative Maze to Assess Novel Object Recognition in Mice