Seems that the initial GO analysis is not correcting for sampling bias (tissue/technology) by using the study specific background?

JT
James Timmons
Nov 19, 2022
protocol Protocol: A Simple Protocol for Informative Visualization of Enriched Gene Ontology Terms
  1. Most GO analysis in published articles is problematic (Wijesooriya, K. et al Plos Comp Biol 2022 & Timmons JA et al Genome Biology 2015) and this is usually driven by failing to control for the background detectable molecules in the experiment and instead just Read more Read less more less
answer Answer
recommend recommend recommend recommend Recommend
follow follow follow follow Follow
share share Share
2 answers
Sort by: most helpful / most recent

Dawn H. Nagel Author Answered Nov 29, 2022

Botany and Plant Sciences, University of California, Riverside

Dear James,

Our protocol was designed to aid in the visualization of the user's GO enrichment results of choice. The intent was to provide a simple script to visualize enriched GO terms, and not for performing GO enrichment. For example, we used the GO enrichment option in TAIR with specific settings and described how this was done. Therefore, regardless of how you perform the GO enrichment and obtained the initial input GO results, our script allows you to visualize the output. Indeed methods that account for biases in GO enrichment analyses should be considered by the users and their desired methods of choice. Thank you for your thoughtful comment.

1 helpful
0 unhelpful
comment 0 comments down up
share Share

James Timmons Answered Nov 29, 2022

YES

Thanks Dawn. The use I’ve noted didn’t understand how to generate a valid initial GO analysis- perhaps because the working example doesn’t emphasise the critical need to use the experiment specific background to generate the adjusted p-values for the regulated list. Perhaps worth making an explicit statement for this requirement within your script to avoid “misuse”? Thanks for replying.

0 helpful
0 unhelpful
comment 0 comments down up
share Share

My answer

Write your answer...

References (optional)

add Add more

post Post an Answer